--- title: MiSafe Child Tracking Watches and the Paradox of Buying Security description: Child care and security is big business. With a global market value of $23bn, the child monitoring systems industry is going nowhere but up.  image: https://reflare.com/hubfs/Blog%20image%20in%20post/MiSafe%20Child%20Tracking%20Watches%20and%20the%20Paradox%20of%20Buying%20Security.png --- [![Reflare home](https://reflare.com/hs-fs/hubfs/Reflare%20website%20images/Reflare%20Logos/reflare%20logo.png?width=421&height=150&name=reflare%20logo.png "Reflare home")](https://reflare.com) [![logo](https://reflare.com/hs-fs/hubfs/Reflare%20website%20images/Reflare%20Logos/logo.png?width=262&height=82&name=logo.png "logo")](https://reflare.com/act3) [![reflare logo](https://reflare.com/hs-fs/hubfs/Reflare%20website%20images/Reflare%20Logos/reflare%20logo.png?width=168&height=60&name=reflare%20logo.png "reflare logo")](https://reflare.com/act3) - [Galena](https://reflare.com/galena) - [Galena Overview](https://reflare.com/galena) - [Galena for Tech Teams](https://reflare.com/technical-teams) - [Galena for L&D Teams](https://reflare.com/learning-development) - [Galena Security and Deployment](https://reflare.com/security-deployment) - Training - [Capture the Flag](https://reflare.com/rctf-reflare-capture-the-flag) - [Developers](https://reflare.com/rcsd) - [Administrators](https://reflare.com/rcsa) - [PCI DSS](https://reflare.com/rcsd) - Audit - [PCI DSS](https://reflare.com/pcidss) - [PCI 3DS](https://reflare.com/pci3ds) - [PCI PIN](https://reflare.com/pcipin) - [PCI DSS ASV](https://reflare.com/pcidssasv) - [Penetration Testing](https://reflare.com/penetration) - [Vulnerability Scanning](https://reflare.com/vulnerability) - [Advisory and Management](https://reflare.com/advisory) - [Research](https://reflare.com/research) - [Anatomy of a Breach](https://reflare.com/research/tag/anatomy-of-a-breach) - [High Tech](https://reflare.com/research/tag/high-tech) - [Infosec Culture](https://reflare.com/research/tag/infosec-culture) - [Infrastructure](https://reflare.com/research/tag/infrastructure) - [Normal People and Infosec](https://reflare.com/research/tag/normal-people-and-infosec) - [WTFWIB](https://whythefuckwasibreached.com/) - [About](https://reflare.com/about) - [Contact](https://reflare.com/contact) - [Company](https://reflare.com/about) - [Careers](https://reflare.com/careers) - [Service Status](https://statuspage.reflare.com/) - [日本語](https://jp.reflare.com/) [Login](https://reflare.com/login) [Buy Now](https://www.hubspot.com/) [Login](https://www.hubspot.com/)Login to your Reflare account - [Galena](https://reflare.com/galena) - [Galena Overview](https://reflare.com/galena) - [Galena for Tech Teams](https://reflare.com/technical-teams) - [Galena for L&D Teams](https://reflare.com/learning-development) - [Galena Security and Deployment](https://reflare.com/security-deployment) - Training - [Capture the Flag](https://reflare.com/rctf-reflare-capture-the-flag) - [Developers](https://reflare.com/rcsd) - [Administrators](https://reflare.com/rcsa) - [PCI DSS](https://reflare.com/rcsd) - Audit - [PCI DSS](https://reflare.com/pcidss) - [PCI 3DS](https://reflare.com/pci3ds) - [PCI PIN](https://reflare.com/pcipin) - [PCI DSS ASV](https://reflare.com/pcidssasv) - [Penetration Testing](https://reflare.com/penetration) - [Vulnerability Scanning](https://reflare.com/vulnerability) - [Advisory and Management](https://reflare.com/advisory) - [Research](https://reflare.com/research) - [Anatomy of a Breach](https://reflare.com/research/tag/anatomy-of-a-breach) - [High Tech](https://reflare.com/research/tag/high-tech) - [Infosec Culture](https://reflare.com/research/tag/infosec-culture) - [Infrastructure](https://reflare.com/research/tag/infrastructure) - [Normal People and Infosec](https://reflare.com/research/tag/normal-people-and-infosec) - [WTFWIB](https://whythefuckwasibreached.com/) - [About](https://reflare.com/about) - [Contact](https://reflare.com/contact) - [Company](https://reflare.com/about) - [Careers](https://reflare.com/careers) - [Service Status](https://statuspage.reflare.com/) - [日本語](https://jp.reflare.com/) [Buy Now](https://www.hubspot.com/) Research #### Share this [Share on Twitter](https://twitter.com/share?url=https://reflare.com/research/misafe-child-tracking-watches-and-the-paradox-of-buying-security&text=MiSafe%20Child%20Tracking%20Watches%20and%20the%20Paradox%20of%20Buying%20Security) [Share on Facebook](https://www.facebook.com/sharer/sharer.php?u=https://reflare.com/research/misafe-child-tracking-watches-and-the-paradox-of-buying-security&t=MiSafe%20Child%20Tracking%20Watches%20and%20the%20Paradox%20of%20Buying%20Security) [Share on LinkedIn](https://www.linkedin.com/shareArticle?mini=true&url=https://reflare.com/research/misafe-child-tracking-watches-and-the-paradox-of-buying-security&t=MiSafe%20Child%20Tracking%20Watches%20and%20the%20Paradox%20of%20Buying%20Security) # MiSafe Child Tracking Watches and the Paradox of Buying Security by [**Reflare Research Team**](https://reflare.com/research/author/reflare-research-team) on Nov 16, 2018 3:38:00 PM Child care and security is big business. With a global market value of $23bn, the child monitoring systems industry is going nowhere but up. However, software vulnerabilities that could be exploited bring the whole proposition into question. First Published 16th November 2018 ![MiSafe Child Tracking Watches and the Paradox of Buying Security](https://reflare.com/hs-fs/hubfs/Blog%20image%20in%20post/MiSafe%20Child%20Tracking%20Watches%20and%20the%20Paradox%20of%20Buying%20Security.png?width=672&height=448&name=MiSafe%20Child%20Tracking%20Watches%20and%20the%20Paradox%20of%20Buying%20Security.png) *There is often a difference between technological intent and technological impact.* 4 min read  |  Reflare Research Team Researchers at the cyber security research firm Pen Test Partners [published their findings](https://www.pentestpartners.com/security-blog/consumer-advice-kids-gps-tracker-watch-security/) on the security features of the MiSafe Child Tracking smartwatch. The watch is designed and marketed as a device that increases the safety of children. Features include the constant monitoring of the child’s location via GPS, the creation of safe zones that alert the parents if the child leaves them, eavesdropping on the child through the watch and initiating a call from the parent's phone to the child’s watch in order to communicate. On paper, these features seem like good ideas to protect children of a very young age. (The notable exception is the eavesdropping feature. Since the watch does not indicate that it is used for recording, this feature alone technically makes the device illegal in many US states and EU member countries.) Knowing where children are at any time and allowing only the parents to call them could theoretically increase response times in cases of accidents or abductions by hours. However, if attackers were able to track and contact the children instead, the scenario quickly turns into a nightmare. Since the child believes that only their parents can call them through the watch, it would be trivial for kidnappers to fake a cold to explain changed voices and lure their victim into an abduction. Unfortunately, this is exactly what appears to be the case. The researchers were quickly able to bypass all security restrictions and take full control of arbitrary watches. While speaking to the BBC, one of the researches went as far as to claim that "it's probably the simplest hack we have ever seen”. ## Impact The impact of this research could be surprisingly broad. According to the researchers, MiSafe merely branded a popular white-label Chinese smartwatch with the given functionality. While no comprehensive lists are available at the point of writing, they estimate that 40,000 MiSafe watches and 53 other brands of child tracking watches are affected by the same or very similar issues. Their assessment is that all child tracking watches are likely to be unsafe. While this may seem to be an exaggeration, they are surprisingly likely to be correct. In niche markets such as child tracking smartwatches, a single large electronics manufacturer usually dominates the entire niche with white-label products that are then branded by distributors. What seems like a competitive space is thus ultimately a single vendor. And a security vulnerability found in one device is likely to affect all devices by that vendor. ## The Paradox of Buying Security The pattern of devices supposedly designed for security leading to insecurity is nothing new. It is somewhat commonplace. From hackable video surveillance cameras to poorly secured smart locks to antivirus software getting attacked by viruses, the products meant to protect consumers often end up harming them. To understand why, we need to look at the concept of “risk surface”. It defines how much risk a given system is being exposed to. While the specifics can become complex very quickly, the basic idea is that certain actions add or reduce the risk surface of a system. So for example, putting a critical system behind a well-monitored firewall will reduce its risk-surface. On the other hand, neglecting to install security fixes on said system will increase its risk surface. What is important to understand is that every protective measure comes with its own risk surface. So while the firewall may protect the systems behind it, it may also have vulnerabilities itself. All decisions are a trade-off. Unfortunately, a lot of devices and software that supposedly work to reduce risk surface introduce a lot of risk surface themselves. This is especially true for devices in niches and those built by young startups as the companies active in this space usually do not have the infrastructure and resources needed to attract high-quality information security talent. ## What you can do In this specific case, the only prudent solution is to avoid using child-tracking smartwatches currently on the market. This includes those sold by your mobile carrier. Mobile carriers sell tracking watches because they are bundled with mobile data plans. They usually do not perform any due diligence on the devices themselves. If you absolutely do require a tracking solution for small children or elderly family members, use features such as Apple’s “Find My Friends” or Google’s “Trusted Contacts” on mainstream smartphones instead. In more general terms, be careful when buying security products, especially those that handle highly personal information such as your location or sound environment. You have to trust that the creator of the device is neither malicious nor incompetent. And while this may be a valid assumption when dealing with giants such as Amazon, Google and Apple, it is a much further stretch when dealing with nameless white-label manufacturers. Topics: [Infrastructure](https://reflare.com/research/tag/infrastructure) #### Share this [Share on Twitter](https://twitter.com/share?url=https://reflare.com/research/misafe-child-tracking-watches-and-the-paradox-of-buying-security&text=MiSafe%20Child%20Tracking%20Watches%20and%20the%20Paradox%20of%20Buying%20Security) [Share on Facebook](https://www.facebook.com/sharer/sharer.php?u=https://reflare.com/research/misafe-child-tracking-watches-and-the-paradox-of-buying-security&t=MiSafe%20Child%20Tracking%20Watches%20and%20the%20Paradox%20of%20Buying%20Security) [Share on LinkedIn](https://www.linkedin.com/shareArticle?mini=true&url=https://reflare.com/research/misafe-child-tracking-watches-and-the-paradox-of-buying-security&t=MiSafe%20Child%20Tracking%20Watches%20and%20the%20Paradox%20of%20Buying%20Security) - Recent - Topics - Archive Recent Topics - [Infosec Culture (113)](https://reflare.com/research/tag/infosec-culture) - [Anatomy of a Breach (60)](https://reflare.com/research/tag/anatomy-of-a-breach) - [Normal People and Infosec (42)](https://reflare.com/research/tag/normal-people-and-infosec) - [High Tech (31)](https://reflare.com/research/tag/high-tech) - [Infrastructure (21)](https://reflare.com/research/tag/infrastructure) - [Capture the Flag (8)](https://reflare.com/research/tag/capture-the-flag) See all Archive - [June 2026 (1)](https://reflare.com/research/archive/2026/06) - [May 2026 (1)](https://reflare.com/research/archive/2026/05) - [April 2026 (1)](https://reflare.com/research/archive/2026/04) - [March 2026 (1)](https://reflare.com/research/archive/2026/03) - [February 2026 (1)](https://reflare.com/research/archive/2026/02) - [January 2026 (1)](https://reflare.com/research/archive/2026/01) - [December 2025 (1)](https://reflare.com/research/archive/2025/12) - [November 2025 (1)](https://reflare.com/research/archive/2025/11) - [October 2025 (1)](https://reflare.com/research/archive/2025/10) - [September 2025 (1)](https://reflare.com/research/archive/2025/09) - [August 2025 (1)](https://reflare.com/research/archive/2025/08) - [July 2025 (1)](https://reflare.com/research/archive/2025/07) - [June 2025 (1)](https://reflare.com/research/archive/2025/06) - [May 2025 (1)](https://reflare.com/research/archive/2025/05) - [April 2025 (1)](https://reflare.com/research/archive/2025/04) - [March 2025 (1)](https://reflare.com/research/archive/2025/03) - [February 2025 (1)](https://reflare.com/research/archive/2025/02) - [January 2025 (1)](https://reflare.com/research/archive/2025/01) - [December 2024 (1)](https://reflare.com/research/archive/2024/12) - [November 2024 (1)](https://reflare.com/research/archive/2024/11) - [October 2024 (1)](https://reflare.com/research/archive/2024/10) - [September 2024 (1)](https://reflare.com/research/archive/2024/09) - [August 2024 (1)](https://reflare.com/research/archive/2024/08) - [July 2024 (1)](https://reflare.com/research/archive/2024/07) - [June 2024 (1)](https://reflare.com/research/archive/2024/06) - [April 2024 (2)](https://reflare.com/research/archive/2024/04) - [February 2024 (1)](https://reflare.com/research/archive/2024/02) - [January 2024 (1)](https://reflare.com/research/archive/2024/01) - [December 2023 (1)](https://reflare.com/research/archive/2023/12) - [November 2023 (1)](https://reflare.com/research/archive/2023/11) - [October 2023 (1)](https://reflare.com/research/archive/2023/10) - [September 2023 (1)](https://reflare.com/research/archive/2023/09) - [August 2023 (1)](https://reflare.com/research/archive/2023/08) - [July 2023 (1)](https://reflare.com/research/archive/2023/07) - [June 2023 (2)](https://reflare.com/research/archive/2023/06) - [May 2023 (2)](https://reflare.com/research/archive/2023/05) - [April 2023 (3)](https://reflare.com/research/archive/2023/04) - [March 2023 (4)](https://reflare.com/research/archive/2023/03) - [February 2023 (3)](https://reflare.com/research/archive/2023/02) - [January 2023 (5)](https://reflare.com/research/archive/2023/01) - [December 2022 (1)](https://reflare.com/research/archive/2022/12) - [November 2022 (2)](https://reflare.com/research/archive/2022/11) - [October 2022 (1)](https://reflare.com/research/archive/2022/10) - [September 2022 (11)](https://reflare.com/research/archive/2022/09) - [August 2022 (5)](https://reflare.com/research/archive/2022/08) - [July 2022 (1)](https://reflare.com/research/archive/2022/07) - [May 2022 (3)](https://reflare.com/research/archive/2022/05) - [April 2022 (1)](https://reflare.com/research/archive/2022/04) - [February 2022 (4)](https://reflare.com/research/archive/2022/02) - [January 2022 (3)](https://reflare.com/research/archive/2022/01) - [December 2021 (2)](https://reflare.com/research/archive/2021/12) - [November 2021 (3)](https://reflare.com/research/archive/2021/11) - [October 2021 (2)](https://reflare.com/research/archive/2021/10) - [September 2021 (1)](https://reflare.com/research/archive/2021/09) - [August 2021 (1)](https://reflare.com/research/archive/2021/08) - [June 2021 (1)](https://reflare.com/research/archive/2021/06) - [May 2021 (14)](https://reflare.com/research/archive/2021/05) - [February 2021 (1)](https://reflare.com/research/archive/2021/02) - [October 2020 (1)](https://reflare.com/research/archive/2020/10) - [September 2020 (1)](https://reflare.com/research/archive/2020/09) - [July 2020 (1)](https://reflare.com/research/archive/2020/07) - [June 2020 (1)](https://reflare.com/research/archive/2020/06) - [May 2020 (1)](https://reflare.com/research/archive/2020/05) - [April 2020 (2)](https://reflare.com/research/archive/2020/04) - [March 2020 (1)](https://reflare.com/research/archive/2020/03) - [February 2020 (1)](https://reflare.com/research/archive/2020/02) - [January 2020 (3)](https://reflare.com/research/archive/2020/01) - [December 2019 (1)](https://reflare.com/research/archive/2019/12) - [November 2019 (2)](https://reflare.com/research/archive/2019/11) - [October 2019 (3)](https://reflare.com/research/archive/2019/10) - [September 2019 (5)](https://reflare.com/research/archive/2019/09) - [August 2019 (2)](https://reflare.com/research/archive/2019/08) - [July 2019 (3)](https://reflare.com/research/archive/2019/07) - [June 2019 (3)](https://reflare.com/research/archive/2019/06) - [May 2019 (2)](https://reflare.com/research/archive/2019/05) - [April 2019 (3)](https://reflare.com/research/archive/2019/04) - [March 2019 (2)](https://reflare.com/research/archive/2019/03) - [February 2019 (3)](https://reflare.com/research/archive/2019/02) - [January 2019 (1)](https://reflare.com/research/archive/2019/01) - [December 2018 (3)](https://reflare.com/research/archive/2018/12) - [November 2018 (5)](https://reflare.com/research/archive/2018/11) - [October 2018 (4)](https://reflare.com/research/archive/2018/10) - [September 2018 (3)](https://reflare.com/research/archive/2018/09) - [August 2018 (3)](https://reflare.com/research/archive/2018/08) - [July 2018 (4)](https://reflare.com/research/archive/2018/07) - [June 2018 (4)](https://reflare.com/research/archive/2018/06) - [May 2018 (2)](https://reflare.com/research/archive/2018/05) - [April 2018 (4)](https://reflare.com/research/archive/2018/04) - [March 2018 (5)](https://reflare.com/research/archive/2018/03) - [February 2018 (3)](https://reflare.com/research/archive/2018/02) - [January 2018 (3)](https://reflare.com/research/archive/2018/01) - [December 2017 (2)](https://reflare.com/research/archive/2017/12) - [November 2017 (4)](https://reflare.com/research/archive/2017/11) - [October 2017 (3)](https://reflare.com/research/archive/2017/10) - [September 2017 (5)](https://reflare.com/research/archive/2017/09) - [August 2017 (3)](https://reflare.com/research/archive/2017/08) - [July 2017 (3)](https://reflare.com/research/archive/2017/07) - [June 2017 (4)](https://reflare.com/research/archive/2017/06) - [May 2017 (4)](https://reflare.com/research/archive/2017/05) - [April 2017 (2)](https://reflare.com/research/archive/2017/04) - [March 2017 (4)](https://reflare.com/research/archive/2017/03) - [February 2017 (2)](https://reflare.com/research/archive/2017/02) - [January 2017 (1)](https://reflare.com/research/archive/2017/01) - [December 2016 (1)](https://reflare.com/research/archive/2016/12) - [November 2016 (4)](https://reflare.com/research/archive/2016/11) - [October 2016 (2)](https://reflare.com/research/archive/2016/10) - [September 2016 (4)](https://reflare.com/research/archive/2016/09) - [August 2016 (5)](https://reflare.com/research/archive/2016/08) - [July 2016 (3)](https://reflare.com/research/archive/2016/07) - [June 2016 (5)](https://reflare.com/research/archive/2016/06) - [May 2016 (3)](https://reflare.com/research/archive/2016/05) - [April 2016 (4)](https://reflare.com/research/archive/2016/04) - [March 2016 (5)](https://reflare.com/research/archive/2016/03) - [February 2016 (4)](https://reflare.com/research/archive/2016/02) See all ### Subscribe by email #### About Reflare We help customers increase cyber resilience with the #1 hands-on IT security training platform. Our developer, administrator, and non-technical user training programs enhance user skills, fulfil your compliance needs, and contribute to developing more secure technologies. Legal - [Terms of Service](https://reflare.com/terms) - [Privacy Statement](https://reflare.com/privacy) - [Cookie Info](https://reflare.com/cookies) - [Copyright and Citation Enquiries](https://reflare.com/citation) - [Contact](https://reflare.com/contact) © 2026 Reflare Ltd, and/or its affiliates.   /   In business since 2009. ```json { "@context" : "https://schema.org", "@type" : "BlogPosting", "author" : { "@type" : "Person", "name" : "Reflare Research Team", "url" : "https://reflare.com/research/author/reflare-research-team" }, "dateModified" : "2023-11-21T12:54:15.710Z", "datePublished" : "2018-11-16T15:38:00.000Z", "headline" : "MiSafe Child Tracking Watches and the Paradox of Buying Security", "image" : [ "https://reflare.com/hubfs/Blog%20image%20in%20post/MiSafe%20Child%20Tracking%20Watches%20and%20the%20Paradox%20of%20Buying%20Security.png" ], "mainEntityOfPage" : { "@id" : "https://reflare.com/research/misafe-child-tracking-watches-and-the-paradox-of-buying-security", "@type" : "WebPage" }, "publisher" : { "@type" : "Organization", "logo" : { "@type" : "ImageObject", "url" : "https://reflare.com/hubfs/Reflare%20website%20images/Reflare%20Logos/logo.png" }, "name" : "Reflare" } } ```